Our new paper about plant trait - environment relationships at the meso-scale published in the Science of the Total Environment

Our new paper by Balázs Deák et al. about the plant trait distributions in topographically heterogeneous dry grasslands has recently been published in the Science of the Total Environment.

The paper is open access, and can be freely downloaded from the website of the journal (please click here).

Reference:

Deák, B., Botta-Dukát, Z., Rádai, Z., Kovács, B., Apostolova, I., Bátori, Z., Kelemen, A., Lukács, K., Kiss, R., Palpurina, S., Sopotlieva, D., Valkó, O. (2024): Meso-scale environmental heterogeneity drives plant trait distributions in fragmented dry grasslands. Science of the Total Environment 947: 174355.

For studying trait-environment relationships, we selected our favourite study system, kurgans (millenia-old ancient burial mounds built by nomadic steppe tribes) that are among the most widespread man-made landmarks in the Eurasian steppe and forest steppe zone (please see our previous publications on these mounds here). We have shown that even at the scale of a few meters, the environmental heterogeneity can considerably shape the distribution of plant traits. Since these small landmarks are characterised by various different microsites, the large trait variation on the mounds can considerably increase community resilience.

Abstract

Environmental heterogeneity shapes the patterns of resources and limiting factors and therefore can be an important driver of plant community composition through the selection of the most adaptive functional traits. In this study, we explored plant trait–environment relationships in environmentally heterogeneous microsite complexes at the meso-scale (few meters), and used ancient Bulgarian and Hungarian burial mounds covered by dry grasslands as a model habitat. We assessed within-site trait variability typical of certain microsites with different combinations of environmental parameters (mound slopes with different aspects, mound tops, and surrounding plain grasslands) using a dataset of 480 vegetation plots. For this we calculated community-weighted means (CWMs) and abundance models. We found that despite their small size, the vegetation on mounds was characterized by different sets of functional traits (higher canopy, higher level of clonality, and heavier seeds) compared to the plain grasslands. North-facing slopes with mild environmental conditions were characterized by perennial species with light seeds, short flowering period, and a high proportion of dwarf shrubs sharply contrasted from the plain grasslands and from the south-facing slopes and mound tops with harsh environmental conditions. Patterns predicted by CWMs and abundance models differed in the case of certain traits (perenniality, canopy height, and leaf dry matter content), suggesting that environmental factors do not necessarily affect trait optima directly, but influence them indirectly through correlating traits. Due to the large relative differences in environmental parameters, contrasts in trait composition among microsites were mostly consistent and independent from the macroclimate. Mounds with high environmental heterogeneity can considerably increase variability in plant functional traits and ecological strategies at the site and landscape levels. The large trait variation on topographically heterogeneous landscape features can increase community resilience against climate change or stochastic disturbances, which underlines their conservation importance.

PhD defence of Katalin Lukács

Congratulations to Kata Lukács, who last week defended her PhD thesis entitled "The mechanism and ecological importance of human-vectored seed dispersal" with summa cum laude. We wish you all the best for the future and continue happy sciencing :)

Kata's PhD topic was the ecological significance of human-vectored seed dispersal. This is a very interesting, new, diverse and human-centered topic :) Kata has carried out her doctoral research with maximum dedication, enthusiasm, and precision.

Start of our first experiment related to human-vectored dispersal in 2017...

And continuation of the same experiment a few years later :)

The dissertation is based on the following articles:

Lukács, K., Tóth, Á., Kiss, R., Deák, B., Rádai, Z., Tóth, K., Kelemen, A., Bátori, Z., Hábenczyus, A.A., Tölgyesi, C., Miglécz, T., Godó, L., Valkó, O. (2024). The ecological footprint of outdoor activities: Factors affecting human-vectored seed dispersal on clothing. Science of the Total Environment 906: 167675. PDF

Valkó, O., Lukács, K., Deák, B., Kiss, R., Miglécz, T., Tóth, K., Tóth, Á., Godó, L., Radócz, S., Sonkoly, J., Kelemen, A. & Tóthmérész, B. (2020). Laundry washing increases dispersal efficiency of cloth-dispersed propagules. NeoBiota, 61, 1. PDF

Lukács, K., & Valkó, O. (2021). Human-vectored seed dispersal as a threat to protected areas: Prevention, mitigation and policy. Global Ecology and Conservation, 31, e01851. PDF

Lukács, K., & Valkó, O. (2022). Magterjedés az emberi ruházaton: megelőzési és védekezési lehetőségek. Természetvédelmi Közlemények, 28, 74–85. [in Hungarian] PDF

If you are interested in the topic, read the doctoral thesis, available here (in Hungarian and English). 

.. or the slightly shorter summary of the doctoral thesis, below:

The doctoral dissertation consists of three chapters aiming to provide an in-depth understanding of epianthropochory and to investigate further details of this process. In the first chapter, we collected data in a multi-site field experiment in three Central-European countries. We collected the diaspores (seeds, fruits) from 88 volunteer participant’s shoes and socks and we studied the effects of landscape-, vector- and plant characteristics. In total of 251 samples (and 2008 subsamples) we identified 229 plant species and we were the first to report the ability for cloth-dispersal in case of 137 species. Most of the identified species were weeds and disturbance tolerant species, which might cause serious environmental problems worldwide. We have shown that site characteristics and vector characteristics strongly influence the human-vectored seed dispersal (HVD) on clothing. In the second chapter, we tested the germination potential after the laundry washing in case of diaspores of 18 plant species. In addition, the adhesion potential of the diaspores was tested on three different clothing and fabric types (blue jeans, polar sweater and cotton socks) before and after the laundry washing. Our results show that washing temperature was the most significant factor affecting germination. Gentle washing at 30 C did not affect the germination potential, while intensive washing (60 C) decreased the seedling number in half of the species. Washing at 60 C desynchronized the germination of eight species. In desynchronized germination, diaspores start germination at different times. If germination is desynchronized, there is a higher chance some diaspores will germinate in a perfect time and establish in a new environment. We found that the lowest proportion of diaspores remained attached on blue jeans. Some of the diaspores may remain on clothing after the laundry washing and may even spread over long distances. In the third study, our aim was to collect biosecurity measures related to HVD on clothing. The biological measures were grouped according to the categories in force: information, self-regulation, legislation, quarantine measures, monitoring, interception and visitor management. Based on the literature, we added useful suggestions to guide to development of future directives.

Unforgettable research expedition in the Kyzyl-Kum desert, Uzbekistan

In early April, we took part in an unforgettable expedition to the Kyzyl-Kum desert in Uzbekistan. Five members of our research team (Balázs Deák, András Kelemen, Réka Kiss, Katalin Lukács, Orsolya Valkó), Csaba Tölgyesi and Zoltán Bátori from the University of Szeged, and Toshpulot Rajabov and Abdubakir Kushbokov from Samarkand State University (SamSu) participated in the expedition. 

The aim of the expedition was to start a large-scale research programme related to Abdubakir's PhD research on the restoration of degraded semi-desert habitats. The research will investigate degradation and regeneration processes along actively used and abandoned watering wells along a grazing intensity gradient. A total of 480 cenological quadrats in 20 sampling areas were surveyed and a total of 480 bags of soil samples, nearly one and a half tons (!!!) were collected. All of this required and will require a lot of preparation, very intensive field work and a lot of post-processing. Currently, Abdubakir is in charge of the concentration of the one and a half tons of soil samples in the SamSu laboratory with the help of a lot of enthusiastic students. A fraction of the soil will be subjected to chemical analysis and root biomass analysis in Uzbekistan, and the seed fraction will be analysed in Hungary using soil seed bank analysis. 

You can read a news about our expedition on the SamSU webpage: https://www.samdu.uz/en/news/53832

We had a very successful, enjoyable and memorable expedition in every respect :) Thank you very much to everyone who was with us on the expedition for all the hard work, organisation, dedication and great company. To the "mining team" for the very hard physical work, to the coenologists for their work, to our Uzbek colleagues for the super organisation and hospitality!

Below you will find many pictures of the unforgettable moments of the expedition :)

Our first group photo: we have just arrived to Kyzyl-Kum and eager to discover its wildlife.

We had very cool transport vehicles: UAZ 4WD cars.

Which needed to be repaired every now and then :)

Or needed some push - as sometimes the roads were wadis:)

One of our everyday activities was the labelling of the sampling bags. Once we did this while the drivers were fixing the motor of the UAZ next to us :)

The interior of the cars was also very cozy and comfortable.

We were always very happy to see camels.

We met a lot of sheep and goat flocks as well.

We have never seen as many tortoises as here in Kyzyl-Kum. The Russian Tortoise (Testudo horsfieldii) was everywhere.

There were a lot of agamas as well.

Our sampling gradient always started next to the watering wells, where there is almost no vegetation due to the heavy grazing and trampling pressure. This zone is called the 'sacrificed zone' by our Uzbek friends - and this term perfectly expresses the essence of these areas.

A perfect example of a sacrificed zone. In some places we counted 1 800 sheep dung per square meter!

With increasing distance from the watering wells, we can observe marked changes in the vegetation. The Artemisia diffusa sagebrushes, a Calligonum bushes, and the abundance of sedges all indicate a good quality rangeland.

Gorgeous tulips were everywhere (Tulipa lehmanniana).

The yellow-flowered version was our favourite, just it was not as common as the red version.

Our favourite plant species was surprisingly a sedge -  Carex physodes. It was just gorgeous.

The "abundance" of grasses is very important source of biomass in the rangelands.

From this angle, it is more visible that indeed it is an important source of biomass!

Calligonum leucocladum bushes are important landmarks.

Siberian Lily (Ixiolirion tataricum)

One of the most important pasture plants is Artemisia diffusa, which provides excellent forage for livestock.

Peganum harmala is a plant that is poisionous even in very small quantitities. It is a typical plant in the sacrificed zones of abandoned wells.

Astragalus villosissimus.

Not easy to guess this: It is Convolvulus hamadae - not in its most spectacular form.

The cutest plant was the Bur Buttercup (Ceratocephala falcata).

But not as cute as the plant - Myosurus minimus - on the sweater of András :)

Moments of field sampling.

Everybody does everything simultaneously.

One of the hardest task was the soil sampling. The procedure on the picture was repeated 1 440 times... 

The boys developed various techniques for soil sampling, one of this was the 'hammer and stone' method.

Another technique was the 'dancing and jumping'.

And the group dancing and jumping :)

This is the precious stone of Balázs, which was his loyal companion during the sampling. It was broken later, but even its half did a very good job.

This is approx. half of all our samples - hundreds of kg-s.

Currently Abdubakir with the help of a lot of enthusiastic students is concentrating the soil samples at the lab of the SamSU.

Idillic campsite near the hills.

Other nice campsite in the desert, in the courtyard of our very kind hosts.

Group photo with our kind hosts (in the middle) and drivers (on the right)

One of the few lunchbreaks that we had :)

Registan - a very famous UNESCO World Heritage Site in Samarkand. One of the most beautiful building in the world!

Registan in the sunlight.

Beautyful courtyard

Wonderful handcrafted pottery in the Samarkand bazar.

Short excursion in a nice hilly landscape.

Ecosystem restoration with local or broad seed provenancing: our new perspectives paper in Biological Conservation

Our new perspectives paper, about the challenges related to seed provenancing in restoration has been recently published in Biological Conservation.

The paper is open access and freely available on the Journal's homepage (please click here).

The citation of the paper:

Török, Katalin, Valkó, Orsolya, Deák, Balázs (2024): Ecosystem restoration with local or broad seed provenancing: Debates and perceptions in science and practice. Biological Conservation 293: 110535. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2024.110535 

In this perspectives article, first we describe the debate on local versus broad provenancing and the benefits and challenges related to the approaches. For this we provided an overview on the current state of the art discussing the pros and cons about local and broad scale provenancing. In order to provide a deeper insight, we compiled a stakeholder survey involving restoration and conservation experts, and practitioners related to this issue. We aimed to highlight the synergies and potential conflicts between practice and research in order to enhance future discussions and by that fine-tuning provenancing frameworks. Finally, we merged the knowledge gained from the literature with that of the stakeholder survey and proposed a simple decision support framework on provenancing in restoration. The framework considers the critical intersections of assessments and decisions, the importance of science and practice at different stages, and includes the role of stakeholders in the process.

Abstract

The UN Decade on Ecosystem Restoration gives new momentum to restoration projects worldwide, which often involve the introduction of plant species. Research evidence shows that restoration success can depend on the seed source. However, there are still debates about the pros and cons of local vs. broad provenancing in restoration. Despite a general agreement on the need for seed transfer regulation, the debate on provenancing challenges or delays the implementation of restoration. In this perspective article, we highlighted this debate that often creates a bottleneck and also examined this issue by surveying the opinion of Hungarian restoration ecologist researchers, conservation practitioners working in restoration, and other conservation experts on the perception of local vs. broad provenancing and the prioritization of further research versus immediate action. Researchers and practitioners had markedly different attitudes; defining aims and prioritization, using genetic knowledge, and species focus were most important to researchers, while broad provenancing,  feasibility, and rapid action were prioritized by practitioners. Comparison of the views of the stakeholders and linking this to a decision framework is a novelty of the study, a step necessary to understand the perception of each other to cooperate for a successful restoration. The results reflect reactive vs. proactive antagonism that should be discussed to identify which approach can be beneficial for restoration and feasible on the given scale. What is needed is to dive into restoration  implementation, jointly find bottlenecks, such as seed sourcing, and solve the problems by using the best available knowledge and necessary compromises.